More proposals leaking from the White House, and this one may have teeth if for nothing else than “smart money” is acting in the bond market for Fannie and Freddie mortgage bonds. (by smart money, I of course mean people with inside information and who apparently can freely trade on it – ahem). Aside from the previously mentioned national landlord proposal it looks like the powers that be are considering throwing (nearly?) everyone who has a government backed loan the opportunity to refinance at current rates. That would work wonders, especially if ‘Operation Twist’ can drive those 30 year rates to sub 4%. Of course those who do not have government backed loans miss out, but fairness is not really something considered during the past 4 years as ‘solution’ after ‘solution’ is thrown against the wall to see what sticks.
While many households have refinanced the past few years – creating a lot of extra free cash flow – this would definitely be a stimulus. People who are underwater and delinquent obviously cannot refinance – unless Uncle Sam says so. (HARP already allows those who have 125% Loan to Value to refinance, so next we can capture those at 140-160-200% I suppose) At current rates, this story estimates a savings of $85B to Americans annually, which would be less than the 2% payroll tax holiday – but that’s going to be extended as well (if not expanded).
- The Obama administration is considering further actions to strengthen the housing market, but the bar is high: plans must help a broad swath of homeowners, stimulate the economy and cost next to nothing.
- One proposal would allow millions of homeowners with government-backed mortgages to refinance them at today’s lower interest rates, about 4 percent, according to two people briefed on the administration’s discussions who asked not to be identified because they were not allowed to talk about the information.
- A wave of refinancing could be a strong stimulus to the economy, because it would lower consumers’ mortgage bills right away and allow them to spend elsewhere. But such a sweeping change could face opposition from the regulator who oversees Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac, and from investors in government-backed mortgage bonds.
- They are also working on a home rental program that would try to shore up housing prices by preventing hundreds of thousands of foreclosed homes from flooding the market. That program is further along — the administration requested ideas for execution from the private sector earlier this month.
- But refinancing could have far greater breadth, saving homeowners, by one estimate, $85 billion a year. Despite record low interest rates, many homeowners have been unable to refinance their loans either because they owe more than their houses are now worth or because their credit is tarnished. More than one in five homeowners with mortgages owe more than their homes are worth.
- As of July, an estimated $2.4 trillion in mortgages backed by Fannie and Freddie carried interest rates of 4.5 percent or higher.
- Exactly how a refinancing plan might work is still under discussion. It is unclear, for example, whether people who are delinquent on their mortgages would be eligible or whether lenders would administer it.
- The idea is appealing because it would not necessarily require Congressional action.
Here is why this appears to be more fire than smoke:
- Investors may suspect a plan is in the works. Fannie and Freddie mortgage bonds had been trading well above their face value because so few people were refinancing, keeping returns on the bonds high. But those bond prices dropped sharply this week.
And… in an oligarchy it is important that the oligarchs support the plan. Our banks do!
- …. banks prefer the refinancing plan.