Krugman’s Certainty

Paul Krugman’s latest opinion piece in The New York Times is one big non-sequitur. Consider the steps of his argument:

1. Unemployment is expected by various forecasters to remain high.

2. Recessions initiated by financial crises are followed by more extended periods of low output and high unemployment than garden-variety recessions.

3. Unemployment is bad – it causes real human suffering.

4. More government spending will alleviate both unemployment and reduced output.

5. Larger deficits are not such a big problem because the costs will be more than offset by the benefits in greater income.

A little bit of evidence is provided for the first three. But the fourth is just an assertion. Will greater stimulus spending shorten the length and lessen the severity of the recession? (Of course, the fifth is dependent on the fourth.) None of the hand-wringing about the badness of the recession and its human costs is relevant to the argument if the remedy is either ineffective or counterproductive.

Scientifically, this is an important question. But in the world of economic journalism it does not seem to matter.

If his advice is accepted, and things get better, he will say “I told you so.”

If his advice is accepted, but things do not get better he will say, “It was not enough stimulus” or “Things were worse than we had expected.”

If his advice is not accepted, and things get worse, he will say “I told you so.”

If his advice is not accepted, and things get better, he will say “That would not have happened without the previous stimulus – we were just lucky this time.”

It used to be said that you could teach a parrot economics. All you have to do is teach him to say “supply and demand.” But the pop Keynesians have improved matters. Now you just have to teach him to say “stimulus.”

About Mario Rizzo 75 Articles

Affiliation: New York University

Dr. Mario J. Rizzo is associate professor of economics and co-director of the Austrian Economics Program at New York University. He was also a fellow in law and economics at the University of Chicago and at Yale University.

Professor Rizzo's major fields of research has been law-and economics and ethics-and economics, as well as Austrian economics. He has been the director of at least fifteen major research conferences, the proceedings of which have often been published.

Professor Rizzo received his BA from Fordham University, and his MA and PhD from the University of Chicago.

Visit: Mario Rizzo's Page

Be the first to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.


*

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.