The President’s Health Care Speech: Some More Reactions

The President’s speech raises a few more questions in my mind.  In no particular order, here’s what I’m wondering:

1) There are references in the speech to reducing costs in Medicare and Medicaid to help pay for the bill.  Why will there still be a need for Medicaid for the non-elderly population if this plan goes forward?  I thought that everyone was going to be eligible for the public option and subsidies would be given to make it affordable for those with low income.  So why would anyone be on Medicaid if they weren’t in a nursing home?

2) The President said that he was serious about not signing a bill “that adds one dime to our deficits — either now or in the future.”  He said:

And to prove that I’m serious, there will be a provision in this plan that requires us to come forward with more spending cuts if the savings we promised don’t materialize. Part of the reason I faced a trillion dollar deficit when I walked in the door of the White House is because too many initiatives over the last decade were not paid for – from the Iraq War to tax breaks for the wealthy. I will not make that same mistake with health care.

So this is the usual procedure of including a trigger in the bill to cut costs if they appear to be getting out of line.  These triggers simply don’t work — Congress finds away around them if they involve any pain to anyone.  So I don’t believe this is effective at all.  I would be persuaded if the implementation of the costly parts of the proposal were delayed until after the savings had been realized.

3) On the subject of whether reform would cover illegal immigrants, the President said:

There are also those who claim that our reform effort will insure illegal immigrants. This, too, is false – the reforms I’m proposing would not apply to those who are here illegally.

I don’t believe this one either.  The most obvious reason is that there was vocal disagreement in the chamber after he said this — if this provision is ever expressed in a bill that passes the House or Senate, it is sure to be stripped out in the conference committee.  Another reason is that to enforce this, we would know who is an illegal immigrant when he or she shows up requesting care and is not in an otherwise universal system.  So how’s that going to work?  Some states will presumably look to formally include them in their systems, like they do with drivers’ licenses, and in the rest of the places they’ll get the same treatment they currently do.

You may also recall that the immigration debacle in 2005 was also a case where the government was unable to do the hard stuff, like securing the border, in advance of the easier stuff, like normalizing the treatment of illegal immigrants.

4) I still haven’t heard or read anything about the details of the insurance reforms; specifically, how will we implement the key combination of community rating, guaranteed issue, and ex post risk adjustment.  The private system cannot work without them.

Disclaimer: This page contains affiliate links. If you choose to make a purchase after clicking a link, we may receive a commission at no additional cost to you. Thank you for your support!

About Andrew Samwick 89 Articles

Affiliation: Dartmouth College

Andrew Samwick is a professor of economics and Director of the Nelson A. Rockefeller Center at Dartmouth College in Hanover, New Hampshire.

He is most widely known for his work on the economics of retirement, and his scholarly work has covered a range of topics, including pensions, saving, taxation, portfolio choice, and executive compensation.

In July 2003, Samwick joined the staff of the President's Council of Economic Advisers, serving for a year as its chief economist and helping to direct the work of about 20 economists in support of the three Presidential appointees on the Council.

Visit: Andrew Samwick's Page

1 Comment on The President’s Health Care Speech: Some More Reactions

  1. priority NOW health care crisis? NOT! add one dime will to our deficits- neither now or future? reason spending cuts? yes them elimination cuts U.S. savings? immigration question on reform obama says” NO” this is A false question PLEASE! reform health care hussein why not stop illegal health care NOW” question? answer” save americans how many of billions of dollars in health care cost NOW? this is not a priority issue crisis? yet you will not enforce provision in bill that strips illegal immigrants from our health care future? if there is provision” i agree writer if this does reach house and senate committees it surly will be stripped out of bill? (TRUST!) QUESTION COMES INTO IMMIGRATION PLAY” with this administration congress secret meetings LA RAZA ACORN E- VERIFY foreign workers visas big trust list agenda direction? like just who is going to be eliminated from cost seniors baby bommers? IMMIGRATION DEBACLE OF 05! you will remember GOVERMENT WAS UNABLE TO DO THE HARD STUFF, LIKE SECURING BORDER after 911 thank you! in advance of easier STUFF, like normalizing treatment of illegal immigrants!!! “wow” i think that issues was over turned by the american people that what didn’t want to normalize undocumented jungle them? yet after that we are nowhere closer to closing securing the border still amnesty live today? yes TRUST them past do for nothing about nothing agenda STUFF!!! yes direction from washington for over 20 years 30 million out of work today” how many over past 20 years or more? industry outsource out! foreign industry solor energy holiday inn! with illegal immigration foreign worker force too? chamber of commerce action of trust too? trust! with so so many un- american types groups this administration has supports and funds ACORN too? yes our health is so so very important to THEM!INDEPENDENT new leadership on one page! like them un- americans are on their some page in washington DC van jones live today. america land of the free! AMEN.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.


This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.