A Ponzi Scheme by Any Other Name

What investor does not want to allocate some portion of his portfolio to safe, liquid investments? Who hasn’t said to his broker or financial planner exactly what The Wall Street Journal reports this morning, ‘I Just Wanted to Play It Safe,’ in regard to the Wall Street Ponzi scheme designated as auction-rate securities?

The WSJ provides these conversations as evidence collected by New York Attorney General Andrew Cuomo in his case against Charles Schwab (NASDAQ:SCHW). As you read these conversations, I am sure it is easy to picture yourself as one of these customers:

Customer from Massapequa, New York

Customer: “You know, I’m not trying to make a ton of money. I just want to play it safe.”

Broker: “Understood.”

Broker: “When you go to get out of this, even though you tell the rep sell it that means you want to stop the auction. The hardest part of this auction is getting into it. That is the tough part. Getting out of it is easy as just selling.”

Customer from Seaford, New York

Customer: “I can just get out every 7 days?”

Broker: “That’s right.”

Customer: “I can just give you 7 days and don’t renew and you put the money back in my account?”

Broker: “That’s correct.”

Customer from Remsenburg, New York

Customer: “It is some kind of short term muni-based piece of paper used as an alternative to [a] money market.”


Customer: “So that is better than what I am getting?”

Broker: “Yeah, yeah. It is better than saving in the money market at the moment.”


Broker: “You pick up about 50 to 60 basis points over what you would get in a money market, and what you are giving up is next day liquidity.”


Customer: “OK. I can adjust it by $100k amounts every week?”

Broker: “In terms of if you wanna get out?”

Customer: “Yeah.”

Broker: “Yeah.”

Customer: “I’ll know a week ahead of time if I wanna make a big investment.”

Customer from New Hyde Park, New York

Broker: “…And it’ll roll over monthly unless you call me and say, ‘Hey [Broker], don’t roll it over anymore.’”

Customer: “Oh, I see. OK.”

Broker: “…And then next month I’ll stop the auction and all the cash will come back to your account.”

Customer: “OK, [Broker], thank you.”

Customer location unidentified

Customer: “Well I need the liquidity because I may buy a house soon.

Broker: “I see.”

Customer: “I sold my house and this is money that’s just there temporarily.”

Broker: “…instead of looking for the highest yield, I would personally look at the highest security. And that would be my second thing. And probably periodic auction rate securities. That would work better than any bond mutual funds for you. That’s my humble opinion.”

Customer: “OK. And it would be safer?”

Broker: “It would be much, much safer, for sure.”

These conversations are eerily similar to scenes in the cheap Wall Street flick The Boiler Room. Where were the SEC, NASD, and FINRA while these blatant misrepresentations were occurring? We know the NASD (FINRA’s parent) purchased ARS. We know FINRA sold these ARS in 2007 prior to the market’s failure.

We know the SEC has blessed a newly designed version of municipal auction-rate security known as x-Tenders. Are municipal money market funds loaded with these newly designed municipal auction-rate securities being marketed with full disclosure? Will we witness a replay of this nightmare?

Aside from a handful of attorneys general (Cuomo in NY, Galvin in MA), who is really trying to pursue justice in this space? Why hasn’t every bank, broker, or money manager involved in this scam been charged?

With upwards of $165 billion remaining frozen in ARS, there are lots of questions and lots of dollars still looking for answers.

About Larry Doyle 522 Articles

Larry Doyle embarked on his Wall Street career in 1983 as a mortgage-backed securities trader for The First Boston Corporation. He was involved in the growth and development of the secondary mortgage market from its near infancy.

After close to 7 years at First Boston, Larry joined Bear Stearns in early 1990 as a mortgage trader. In 1993, Larry was named a Senior Managing Director at the firm. He left Bear to join Union Bank of Switzerland in late 1996 as Head of Mortgage Trading.

In 1998, after 15 years of trading and precipitated by Swiss Bank’s takeover of UBS, Larry moved from trading to sales as a senior salesperson at Bank of America. His move into sales led him to the role as National Sales Manager for Securitized Products at JP Morgan Chase in 2000. He was integrally involved in developing the department, hiring 40 salespeople, and generating $300 million in sales revenue. He left JP Morgan in 2006.

Throughout his career, Larry eagerly engaged clients and colleagues. He has mentored dozens of junior colleagues, recruited at a number of colleges and universities, and interviewed hundreds. He has also had extensive public speaking experience. Additionally, Larry served as Chair of the Mortgage Trading Committee for the Public Securities Association (PSA) in the mid-90s.

Larry graduated Cum Laude, Phi Beta Kappa in 1983 from the College of the Holy Cross.

Visit: Sense On Cents

Be the first to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.