Insider Trading Regulatory Bubble

After going easy for years on the fraudster Bernard Madoff, the Securities and Exchange Commission is now engaged in an all-out war against insider trading.  After financial crisis comes regulatory frenzy—so it has been for some 300 years. Both the SEC and the Dodd-Frank Act are right on cue in this long-running political show.

Boom-bust cycles come with bubble laws, to use a term from Larry Ribstein of the University of Illinois College of Law, one of the legal scholars who looked at the historic trend.  What causes securities regulation? Professor Stuart Banner of UCLA Law faculty has a succinct answer: “In a nutshell, crashes.

The 1720 South Sea Bubble in Britain gave rise to the Bubble Act. The 1792 crash in New York resulted in the first significant securities regulation in America. The 1929 crash led to the1930s securities laws. After the bursting of the late 1990s technology-driven stock bubble came the Sarbanes-Oxley Act of 2002. And the collapse of the twin credit and property bubbles heralded the passage of Dodd-Frank this year.

Enforcement of existing laws follows a similar cyclical pattern. Amitai Aviram of the University of Illinois College of Law shows that SEC enforcement actions tend to move in opposite direction to the stock market.  Fraud is often perceived as the cause of a slump because it offers a vivid, concrete and easy-to-understand explanation, argues Professor Aviram. This creates political pressure on regulators to make special efforts after market downturns.

But isn’t insider trading a real problem, whatever the political motivation of regulators and legislators? Not necessarily. Donald Boudreaux of George Mason University has made a powerful case that insider trading is good for markets and investors. The trades provide information and cause markets to adjust quicker to underlying corporate realities, keeping prices honest.

Moreover, the line between trades that are criminal and those that are not is vague and impossible to police.  “Parsing the difference between legal and illegal insider trading is futile—and a disservice to all investors,” Professor Boudreaux wrote in a Wall Street Journal piece.

The real problem is the fraudulent schemes that will be hatched by future Madoffs in the next boom. By then, regulators will be back to their complaisant mode. The current onslaught on a wide range of trading may be politically expedient, but it is at best a diversion from what should be the top regulatory priority in financial markets, namely fighting lies and fraudulent claims. At worst, regulators are criminalizing activity that is potentially beneficial. The main effect may be to reduce information flow to shareholders.

Meanwhile, various federal bureaucracies have just began the process of making arcane rules to implement thousands of pages of additional regulation. Richard Epstein recently pointed out that the two laws passed this year, ObamaCare and Dodd-Frank, are so massive as to throw administrative rulemaking into disarray.

It’s all another burden on the economy and on honest folk. Professor Ribstein argues that laws made in unusual circumstances discourage proper consideration of what can be achieved and at what cost.

Centuries of experience suggest none of this will stop the next Madoff.  He knows how to work the regulatory state.

Disclaimer: This page contains affiliate links. If you choose to make a purchase after clicking a link, we may receive a commission at no additional cost to you. Thank you for your support!

About Chidem Kurdas 58 Articles

Chidem Kurdas is a financial journalist, analyst and writer.

Throughout her career she has held numerous positions, including: Research Analyst at Thomson Reuters, New York Bureau Chief at HedgeWorld, News Editor at Infovest21, Senior Associate Editor at Medical Economics Publications at The Thomson Corporation. She is currently Editor at Opalesque Futures Intelligence.

She holds a PhD in Economics from New School University.

Visit: Mutual Fund Smarts

1 Comment on Insider Trading Regulatory Bubble

  1. Unfortunately the online sphere has many areas of capacious involved with to parents.
    Computer monitoring has captivated on a greater importance from the mould decade as more children compel ought to access to the internet.
    It is easy as pie in regard to anyone to accidentally blunder chance across network pages that seat obscene or untamed material.
    These websites can take a joking problamatic import on children.
    These days you can superintend what is prospering on with computer monitoring software.
    This software longing assist you to grasp all keystrokes, websites, logins, and more.
    It purpose also set apart you to stop users from accessing any website.
    The strict thing in the [url=] computer monitoring [/url] is that you can do it from anywhere you demand access to a computer.
    You intent be gifted to login and substantiate on all aspects on occupation from a attach website.
    In additionally you will-power be expert to conceive of all emails and even talk activity.
    You can stylish record your offspring and mind them ok from an unresearched internet.

    Another talents of computer monitoring software is to monitor employees and a halt them from accessing non go interdependent websites.
    This can advise redeem your duty and also tend your computers from x-rated trap locale related viruses.
    At the last moment if you doubtful a spouse of cheating than computer monitoring software is after you.
    You longing post-haste catch sight of manifest if there are cheating or not.
    The software can be worn on a desktop, laptop, or ordered a smartphone.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.


This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.