I just reviewed the complaint filed by the SEC as plaintiff against Madoff CFO, Frank DiPascali Jr. as defendant. For anybody interested in the dynamics of our markets and regulatory system, this 33 page document is a must read.
Many highlights but to me the following jumps out:
1. DiPascali was a college dropout who rose to become a CFO of a supposed major financial money manager. Come on. Any legitimate feeder fund and any legitimate regulator should have immediately questioned the credibility and qualifications of this individual rising to that position.
2. Madoff did not officially become a registered investment adviser until 2006. To that point, his entire business would have been regulated by the SEC AND NASD. Why does the NASD, the parent organization of FINRA seem to get a pass in this scandal.
3. The financial subterfuge is so widespread that it seems that regulators would almost have been trying to miss this fraud. I view this SEC complaint as much an indictment of the regulators as it is an indictment of Madoff and DiPascali. As Harry Markopolos asserted, he knew it was a fraud 5 minutes after looking at it and it took him 4 hours to prove it!!
4. Madoff’s fraudulent activities have operated for a very long time. How do we know? The complaint highlights that while Madoff started in the 1960s,
Over time this advisory business expanded and various accountants and financial advisors began soliciting individual investors around the country and providing the money they raised to BMIS. These “feeders” sometimes issued to investors promissory notes that guaranteed high rates of return ~ 19%) and then invested the proceeds with BMIS at higher rates promised by Madoff (~ 21%), seeking to pocket the difference for themselves. Unlike the friends and family accounts, Madoff and BMIS did not deal directly with these individual investors. Instead, Madoff dealt with the feeders and set up aggregate, pooled accounts at BMIS for each feeder, leaving it to the feeder to deal with the individual investors, issue statements to such investors, and make distribution payments to them.
21% guaranteed returns? Are you kidding me? Regulators missed that?
I repeat my assertion the other day in writing Madoff CFO, Frank DiPascali, Singing Like a Canary,
Who were the regulators from NASD/FINRA and the SEC responsible for monitoring the Madoff operation? Are they nervous as well? Will investigators dare to pursue this angle?
I strongly encourage people to fully read this complaint. It is an easy read. One will receive a birds eye view into this enormous financial fraud and equally enormous case of financial regulatory malfeasance.