QE2 Report Card

A plethora of reports on QE2 are coming in with low grades. It launched to a bumpy start, and many observers thought it wouldn’t have much of an impact in the real world (vs the worlds of speculation and expectations).

Global Bond Rout

Most noteworthy is that rates have gone up rather than down, and up quite a bit – 60 bp in the ten-year – enough so it has pummeled the bond market and led to descriptions of a Global Bond Rout. PragCap shows how dramatic the reversal has been, albeit we are still below yields earlier in the year:

Doug Short piles on, showing how since the actual QE2 announcement in November, the rate increases have been dramatic:

Econbrowser did a careful, somewhat scholarly review, and generally concluded that whatever impact it was supposed to have had is being swamped but other events. Their primary criticism is that the Fed has executed QE2 in the mid-range of Treasuries, rather than the ten-year (or longer) bonds.

Banks Lending Again?

Another purpose of QE was to right the banks, encouraging them to lend again. Banks make money borrowing short and lending long, so a rise in long rates should encourage capital formaton.

John Mauldin adds a long, careful assessment of QE2 in his weekly newsletter, reprinted here. He sees unintended consequences to QE2: a global sell-off in sovereign debt. Why?

virtually every country in the world is grappling right now with how fast we get out of our fiscal stimulus and much do we worry about this longer term problem of debt

This may explain why rates spiked after the Obama tax deal was announced – it reflects more of the stimulus mentality, piling on more debt, than a change of approach to grapple with excess debt. The bond vigilantes disapprove.

John went on to ask whether QE2 had begin to fix the core problem of capital formation – in other words, are the banks ending again? The answer is a resounding no. Credit continues to contract, and now with the long bond over 4%, mortgages have gone up, further hammering the housing recovery. Indeed, housing has started a double-dip.

Inflation Increasing?

A third goal was to reflate the Dollar, with the view that rising prices would also encourage capital formation. I have always found this goal an odd one, perhaps a post hoc, ergo propter hoc fallacy looking back at the Great Depression. When FDR broke with gold, the USD fell and we had inflation. Did the recovery come for other reasons, brining inflation, or did inflation drive the recovery? In any event, in coming the financial blogs I have seen sophisticated arguments for increased inflation expectations, but no signs of inflation (other than asset speculation). Indeed, the inflation-adjusted Treasuries, TIPS, have not signaled higher inflation, rising with the ten-year not ahead of it. Instead, bonds are weak because of QE, not inflationary expectations:

The market sees the deflationary forces mixed with the inflationary signs and trades it to a draw. The market is shooting bonds because it is afraid and confused about the distortions that QE is causing.

About Duncan Davidson 228 Articles

Affiliation: NetService Ventures

Duncan is an advisor to NetService Ventures, where he focuses on digital media and the mobile Internet.

Previously he was at four start-ups: Xumii, a mobile social service based on a Social Addressbook; SkyPilot Networks, the performance leader of wireless mesh systems for last-mile access, where he was the founding CEO; Covad Communications (Amex: DVW, $9B market cap at the peak), the leading independent DSL access provider, where he was the founding Chairman; InterTrust Technologies ($9B market cap at the peak), the pioneer in digital rights management technologies, now owned by Sony and Philips, where he was SVP Business Development and the pitchman for the IPO.

Before these ventures, Duncan was a partner at Cambridge Venture Partners, an early-stage venture firm, and managing partner of Gemini McKenna, a joint venture between Regis McKenna's marketing firm and Gemini Consulting, the global management consulting arm of Cap Gemini.

He serves on the board or is an adviser to Aggregate Knowledge (content discovery), Livescribe (digital pen), AllVoices (citizen journalism), Xumii (mobile social addressbook), Verismo (Internet settop box), and Widevine (DRM for IPTV).

Visit: Duncan Davidson's Blogs

Be the first to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.


*